I beg your Pardo... and Spiffo settles the JPP vs. Reggie White comparison...

[Spoken in a perfect Brizzini dialect] ---"As for blurb inspiration, I think we should go with the best Eagles Player to 'don' the Numbers from 1 to 99...All time. You can split it in 5 parts. Like 1-19.. 20-39..40-59..etc.. Give a little blurb about how good or great each player was..Also time he
played on the Eagles. It will be fun for this dead period. You can even "puff" the article with; "what's in a number..."--- luck, destiny,
tradition, et cetera..."
"I will start....

1) Tony Franklin
2) David Akers
3) Eddie Murray
4) Max Runager - yes better than Kevin Kolb
5) Donovan McNabb
6) Bubby Brister
7) Ron Jaworski
8) Paul McFadden
9) Sonny Jurgensen or Joe Pisarcik (Polish Cannon)
10) Desean Jackson
11) Norm Van Brocklin
12) Randall Cunningham
13) *******There is none..enough said*******
14) Swede Hanson but really I liked AJ "Touchy" Feeley..
15) Steve Van Buren
16) Norm Snead ..not Chad Hall.btw.why is Chad Hall even on this team?
17) Harold Carmichael...legend!
18) Jeremy Maclin..yes over Donte Stallworth
19) Tom Dempsey..half a foot, half an arm, but whole heart!!!! Loved Him!
20) Brian Dawkins...special nod goes to Andre Waters.."
"Now go take care of your business, as I must rejoin my family's celebration..."
THANK YOU, Don Pardo, for your inspiration, you are truly godfather to us all...
Speaking of numbers, we all know who #91 would be in Don Pardo's Numbers Game--- the late great Reggie White. And our resident IT guy Spiffo (aka Tom Frank) crunched some numbers for us to help squash the shallow but trending comparison of the Giants' Jason Pierre-Paul to a modern day Reggie White.

Why Reggie White will always be better than JPP
By Tom (Spiffo) Frank
There has been some discussion about why JPP is the next Reggie White. While I know (and everybody with two eyes knows) that JPP is good, he just isn’t Reggie White good. Sunbutts was speculating the other day that when JPP retires, fans will be saying. “Reggie who?” While this both shows his ignorance and the wide blue streak down his back, it brings up an interesting point. Even if JPP smashes every record held by Reggie White, would that make him the better player and erase Reggie from the history books? I don’t think so, and here’s why:
1) Reggie White was a phenom. I don’t mean that he played beyond his abilities, but he played beyond everyone’s abilities. He was crazy good. JPP is a very physical athlete. Doing several back flips down the football field in full pads is impressive and shows his athleticism and raw talent. Maybe he would have been a good ballerina.
2) Reggie White was an anchor. Don’t get me wrong, the defense was good without Reggie, but with Reggie in there, there was no stopping it. JPP is part of a gang. His Defense was good without him, and is still good with him. Unstoppable? Hardly.
3) The Eagles had a defense with a “name” like “the Steel Curtain”, “Blitzburgh”, and “the Orange Crush”… With Reggie and Jerome Brown in there, we had “Gang Green”. What’s the Giants’ D name? “The Fake Injury D”?
4) Reggie broke records and players alike. He didn’t mind smarshing heads to get where he wanted. He didn’t care about the record books and the statistics he was putting up, he liked to play the game. JPP seems like a nice guy, but I don’t see him helping anybody but himself.
5) Reggie had class. The “Minister of Defense” would beat a man down into the mud and then help him up after the whistle. He would smile while he sacked the QB, then help him up and give him a friendly word. JPP will get the sack then do his celebration dance.
Statistically, Reggie dominated his entire career:
Year – GP – GS – Sacks – Tackles – Assists
1985 – 13 - 12 - 13 - 100 - 0
1986 – 16 - 16 - 18 - 98 - 0
1987 – 12 - 12 - 21 - 76 - 0
1988 – 16 - 16 - 18 - 133 - 0
1989 - 16 – 16 - 11 - 123 - 0
1990 – 16 - 16 - 14 - 83 - 0
1991 – 16 - 16 - 15 - 100 - 0
1992 - 16 – 16 - 14 - 81 - 0
1993 - 16 - 16 - 13 - 79 - 0
1994 - 16 - 15 - 8 - 35 - 14
1995 - 15 - 13 - 12 - 31 - 11
1996 - 16 - 16 - 8.5 - 30 - 9
1997 - 16 - 16 - 11 - 31 - 15
1998 - 16 - 16 - 16 - 33 - 13
2000 - 16 - 16 - 5.5 - 15 - 1
Meanwhile JPP is doing very well in his second year:
Year – GP – GS – Sacks – Tackles – Assists
2010 - 16 - 0 - 4.5 - 17 - 5
2011 - 16 - 12 - 16.5 - 72 - 21
Furthermore, Reggie went to 13 Pro-Bowls and was All-Pro 8 times. JPP has been to 1 Pro-Bowl and was All-Pro once. I’m sure that JPP will attend several more Pro-Bowls, if they continue the game, but with a shorter life-span of players these days, I don’t think he’ll make 13.
Can JPP keep it up for 15 years? I don’t know. And neither does anybody else. It’s a ridiculous comparison to put a second year player up against a legend.

Spiffo as I imagine him in my movie, played by Ed Begley, Jr.
Thanks to Spiffo for that piece... Open Mike Week continues next time with Dutchie and PPW, and with Dr. Funt on deck...






